Of course II, this has and will re-open the debate about when to review, and is it fair to the public to see a show in previews, blah blah blah.
Earlier this week, Ken Davenport ran a blog post about the public's true opinion about whether or not a show being in previews mattered. He did a un-scientific poll of people standing in line at the TKTS booth, and found that the vast majority of people polled didn't care as long as the show was good. One of my favorite blog-buddies in the entire world, GratuitousV, took exception to the poll and is vehement that the public is being duped by shows that aren't ready being sold at full price.
I can see and understand her point, and I even agree with her that stars of shows vacation schedules should be made universally known ahead of time so people can plan trips to see their favorites. (Kudos, by the way to A Little Night Music and Women on the Verge of Nervous Breakdown; both shows posted vacation schedules for Catherine, Angela, Patti and Brian Stokes before a single ticket was sold to the public.) And I also think it would be great to go back to the old days where there was a preview schedule of prices - again kudos to Women on the Verge, it wasn't much, but previews were cheaper. And I do feel for people who plan whole vacations around a performance that gets cancelled. Full refunds are never enough to equal that disappointment.
Further, it has been suggested but not a few people - though I will quote GratuitousV because she is well spoken and because I know she understands I'm not attacking her personally - that the public should be made fully aware that a show in previews might have the following issues. And I have seen each of these separately from other bloggers and online chatters.
"Would you want to see a show in which some of the actors may not know their lines, the sets may get stuck, forcing the show to stop, and songs or dialogue may get added or cut as performances progress toward opening night? That's what a "preview" really means in some cases."
Let me address each element:
- Actors may not know their lines - as I said neither thing happened in Verge or Spider-Man. But I can say that it has happened many times in my experience to shows ALREADY open - to a full-price paying all-knowing audience. And frankly, I think I find it more objectionable for a running show (though I generally find such bloopers the very stuff that makes LIVE theatre so great), especially when said performer is legendary and actually embraced for not knowing her lines for the entire run. I'm talking, of course, of Elaine Stritch. Didn't know lines, labored over her one song, and had the balls to mug happily over being so ill-prepared. Why is it that she is applauded for it, but an actor in Verge or Spider-Man should be taken to task for it? I have seen dozens of actors flub lines and lyrics, and always had fun watching them work through it.
- The sets may get stuck - this can/does and will continue to happen. Ask the guy at the Globe theatre, who fell through an open trap door during the opening of one of Shakespeare's plays. We got a whole saying out of that - "Break a Leg!" means good luck now. And that was waaayyyy back. More recent examples that I can verify for having witnessed them myself: At Les Miz, the revolving stage got stuck, causing a 20 minute delay, an offer of full refunds, and about 2/3 of the show done with the actors doing their best to recreate the feel without the movement. Legally Blonde - Paulette's beauty parlor got caught in a curtain, bringing the show to a halt for ten minutes. I saw Cats TWICE when the tire didn't levitate, and Wicked on tour when Elphaba didn't actually defy gravity. Watching the remainder of Act One of Grease (94 revival) when they couldn't get Greased Lightning out of the way was a real treat - Rosie O'Donnell's ad-libs were PRICELESS.
- Songs or dialogue may be added or cut - Really? You mean it isn't 100% done the first dozen or so times the show is performed? How about AFTER the show opens and changes are made? Ask Julie Andrews about Camelot or Victor/Victoria. How about adding an unlisted song as a finale!!?? Ask the folks at American Idiot or Shrek: The Musical. Then there's The Lion King AND Les Miserables who both cut whole songs and scenes out of their shows well into their runs. All of these happened AFTER previews, and people weren't calling for beheading or even refunds. And I won't even go into the whole Scarlet Pimpernel thing where one version was being performed while another was being rehearsed... And what about when shows leave Broadway and are changed for the tour? Whole songs and scenes are dropped and/or re-worked. Talk about getting ripped off - people think the National Tour is a replica of the Broadway production. Again, no lines for refunds... no public outcry.
Yes, a preview means all of those things. But all of those things could and do apply to officially opened productions, too.
And changing the opening night, which started this rant in the first place, is also their right. Spider-Man: Turn Off the Dark IS, and I can verify it, the biggest, most complicated show EVER. Bumps, starts and stops and postponements are going to happen. Usually, people moan and groan when a producer won't stand behind his own show (The Scottsboro Boys, anyone?) and let it find an audience, or complain because more time to work on a show is needed but not given. And yet, here we are slinging arrows at a producer who is putting his money where his mouth is. He's letting his team get the show where they want it. And, I understand that any performance that was halted - even the notorious one with Christopher Tierney plunging to serious injury - FULL refunds have been offered or seats to another performance have been given. Not bad in that case, because the audience only missed 7 minutes of the entire show - the ending, which is/was incomplete at the time, anyway. I also understand, though I can't verify it, that partial refunds have been offered to folks at those first few previews as well.
All of that said, I can see and understand people's ire over the ever changing date, and that yes, there is plenty of blame for this to be laid at everyone's feet. But at this point, what difference does it make, really? It is a sellout almost every night, and looks to be around for awhile no matter what. Hell, Beatlemania never officially opened and ran for years, anyway!
As for me? Well I rank the early previews of Women on the Verge and Spider-Man amongst the most thrilling, exciting times I've had in the theatre. There is nothing more LIVE than LIVE theatre at its rawest and most vulnerable.
Comments? Leave one here, email me at firstname.lastname@example.org or Tweet me!